Michelle O’Connell was shot to death on September 2, 2010, after arguing with her boyfriend, St Johns Sheriff’s Office Deputy, Jeremy Banks’.

The weapon that delivered the fatal shot was Jeremy’s police-issued firearm.  Jeremy then made a disturbing 9-1-1. After a short investigation, her death was officially ruled a ‘suicide.’ Subsequent official investigations did not change this conclusion. Eight years later, a private citizen named Eli Washtock, began investigating Michelle’s death, but before he could finish, he was murdered.